Are you actually revising?


Hi Reader!

This week, I hit a podcasting milestone: Episode 50 of The Better Writer Podcast went live on Tuesday!

I ended my series on first draft revision mistakes by talking about one of the saddest revision mistakes I see: writers who think they’re revising but aren’t actually doing the work.

These are the writers who come to me with a book they’ve already queried. A book that has already been rejected by agent after agent after agent.

These writers are always mystified by their failure.

I’m not.

Each one of these “query-ready” books has first draft issues lingering in the first chapter.

These writers aren’t lazy or unmotivated. They thought they’d revised their books. They thought they’d gotten them ready for publication.

They hadn’t.

Sure, they’d polished scenes and made changes. Just not the ones that actually mattered.

I’ve talked a lot about the misconceptions writers have about the revision process, and those are definitely a factor, but I think there’s another issue at play here too: we don’t know what revision means to other writers.

Examples of poorly written paragraphs are everywhere. Examples of poorly written outlines? Not so much.

If you don’t know what it actually means to revise, how can you know what to do when it’s your turn?

So in the spirit of demystifying revision, here are some of the changes I’ve guided writers through as an editor & book coach:

  • Cutting 35,000 words from a dark fantasy adventure novel because the story went on a side quest that read more like cozy fantasy. That subplot absolutely could have worked in a different book, just not the one that this writer actually wanted to create.
  • Choosing between two genres that seem similar on the surface but actually have wildly different expectations (dystopian fiction vs. dystopian romance, if you’re wondering). The writer wanted to prioritize elements of both but had to make a choice because the readers of these genres do not want the same thing.
  • Rewriting every word of a story in deep point-of-view to create a more engaging reader experience.
  • Cutting an entire point-of-view character’s storyline because they weren’t the person with the most at stake or the most interesting perspective on the conflict.
  • Changing the structure of a magical competition to make the worldbuilding more logical while keeping the stakes high from start to finish.
  • Adjusting a romance arc to avoid having readers root for the wrong love interest who wasn’t even supposed to be a love interest at all.
  • Putting the romance arc for the main couple on the page when it was merely implied in the first draft.

It’s a lot, I know, and these are just the changes I came up with off the top of my head while drafting this email.

Revision doesn’t always mean big changes, but big changes must be on the table, otherwise you’re not revising.

If we only look at published, polished books, you might think they came into the world in that basic form and only needed sprucing up.

What we don’t see are all the scenes left on the cutting room floor. The scenes that got rethought, rewritten, and revised ten different times with input from ten different people before that book arrived in your hands.

That’s why I love repurposing my sh*tty first drafts as examples of what not to do and what could be done better in a real in-progress novel.

It’s also why I’m passionate about teaching writers a process for making these big changes without getting completely overwhelmed or second-guessing every change along the way. It’s my way of making the revision process just a bit more transparent along the way and letting writers learn from my mistakes.

Now, I’m curious. What’s the biggest change you’ve made or contemplated making in revision?

Hit reply and let me know!

All the best,

Olivia

​
P.S. My Black Friday sale is coming! I’ll be sharing a full announcement email on Sunday, but you can get a preview on this week’s podcast episode :)

Your story matters. Let's make it great.

Curious to know how I can help? Check out my services here. I can't wait to work with you, so you can write the book your future readers are waiting for!

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

The Better Writer Weekly

Subscribe to the Better Writer Weekly for actionable writing advice, personal stories, and tips for making your entire life better (whatever that means to you).

Read more from The Better Writer Weekly
Text reads The Better Writer Weekly Olivia Bedford and has an image of Olivia Bedford smiling and looking at the camera.

Hi Reader, I talk all the time about the importance of revising high-level elements of your story before you start editing line-level elements. But what are those high-level elements exactly and why are they so important to get right? Here’s an overview of my top four and how they affect the reader experience: Conflict: Write this one down on a Post-it, highlight it, underline it, and circle it three times. Your story needs conflict. The type of conflict will depend on your genre and the...

Text reads The Better Writer Weekly Olivia Bedford and has an image of Olivia Bedford smiling and looking at the camera.

Hi Reader, This month is all about first drafts for me. I spent October talking about how to use writing challenges to your advantage, and I know many of you are participating in some version of NaNoWriMo or Novel November right now. You’re flying through your first draft (or, at least making steady progress), and whether you’re on pace to hit 50k in one month or not, you can and will finish that book!! Then, you’ll be ready for the real work. Yes, drafting is hard, but it’s only the...

Image of a group of teenagers in Mario Kart costumes including Olivia dressed as Shy Guy with a red robe, white and black face paint, and a box painted to look like a kart.

Hi Reader, I have a confession to make: I went trick or treating until I was a senior in high school. I know that for some people, that’s way too old. Shouldn’t I have been going to a party by that age, or better yet, staying home and working on college apps? I know that some people see teenagers with candy bags and half-assed costumes and see grifters trying to take candy that should be going to cute kids in princess dresses and cowboy costumes. As a teacher, I even had students tell me that...